03/08/2026 ~ Third Sunday in Lent ~ Exodus 17:1-7; Psalm 95; Romans 5:1-11; John 4:5-42 ~ HARPSWELL TV VIDEO: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ME9nRjc_UKg
Universal Salvation
“At the appointed time, when we were still powerless, Christ died for godless people.” — Romans 5:6.
I suspect most of you know I’m a member of A.S.C.A.P., the American Society of Composers, Authors and Publishers, as a writer of lyrics. I’ve written lyrics for both hymns and secular songs. I’ve also collaborated on three faith based cantatas.
Over time I’ve written lyrics for new music, church and secular— working with three different composers. Over time I’ve written new lyrics for well known hymn tunes.
And so an article in Christianity Today caught my attention as it asked what hymns continue to be used in churches over the course of time? While some think hymns are sacred, akin to Scripture, the article questioned that premise.
It was, if anything, an academic analysis. It studied the data and asked what hymns have survived in hymnals over time?’
Now, I know people complain about changes in the words of hymns. But change is commonplace. Indeed, in the introduction to the 1913 Pilgrim Hymnal the editors stated they changed the words to match their times.
I also need to note the singing of hymns is fairly new in Congregational churches as the practice was not widely accepted until the early 1800s. Up until theb the standard was antiphonal singing of Psalms. (Slight pause.)
As to that aforementioned article, what hymns made the cut in hymnals of Mainline churches across generations and still appear in today’s versions? Here’s the data. In 28 different editions of hymnals in six Mainline Protestant denominations over the course of years there have been 4,905 hymns.
The denominations are the Episcopal Church, with four different editions since 1892; Congregational, five editions since 1897; American Baptist, four editions since 1883; Lutheran, five editions since 1899; Methodist five editions since 1878; Presbyterian, five editions since 1885.
In the course of 148 years a typical hymnal had between 500 and 700 hymns. Generally in each edition, 250 to 350 of the hymns would be older, 250 to 350 newer.
So the process of constant change is old one. While there was an outpouring of new hymns in the Victorian era, they make up less than 20 percent the hymns now in use. (Slight pause.) Well, I’m sure everyone wants to know how many hymns made the cut, survived in all 28 versions of the hymnals and are still there, right? O.K. (Slight pause.)
This is the list of hymns and the years they were written. I will start with the newest one. There is one caveat: by definition, these all predate 1878 so that eliminates a lot of well known hymns written at a later date. And there are only 13 hymns that survived.
The list: Crown Him with Many Crowns, written in 1851; Abide with Me, 1847; Come, Ye Thankful People, Come, 1844; Holy, Holy, Holy!, 1826; In the Cross of Christ I Glory, 1825; How Firm a Foundation, 1787; Glorious Things of Thee Are Spoken and All Hail the Power of Jesus’ Name, both 1779; Love Divine, All Loves Excelling, 1747; Guide Me, O Thou Great Jehovah, 1745; Jesus Shall Reign Where E’er the Sun, 1719; When I Survey the Wondrous Cross, 1707; last and the oldest— O Sacred Head, Now Wounded, written sometime in the 12th Century.
Do note: there have been multiple translations from the Latin of the seven verse poem on which O Sacred Head is based. Each verse has ten lines. And all the translations have a different take on what the Latin says. Just for starters, the Latin title of the poem is Salve Mundi Salutare which means Hail, the World’s Redeemer— not O Sacred Hear— nothing like it. So it seems changing words is not new, is it? (Pause.)
Brian Wren, a British hymn writer, came to Bangor Seminary when I was there. In one lecture he picked up a hymnal and banged on the cover (the pastor bangs on a hymnal cover) like that.
Then he said: “We make a big mistake by putting hard covers on hymnals. It makes people think hymns are permanent, eternal, akin to Scripture. They are none of those. Hymns are cups dipped into the flowing stream of artistic interpretation about Scripture, works of art for today meant to help us understand today.” (Slight pause.)
I sometimes say Scripture can be explained with several crucial points. God loves us and wants to covenant with us, wants be in relationship with us. Therefore, without condemnation, God invites us to love God and to love neighbor. That’s not complex, is it?
However, getting to a place of refined Biblical interpretation, gleaning the subtly of meanings from Scripture can be a complex task. Here’s a brief explanation of one part of that task.
When examining Scripture, one must attempt to seek what a passage might have meant to those who first read it or heard it. Hence, you need to know something about the era in which the passage was written, something about the people, their way of life, the economy, the social structure, etc., etc., etc.
Only when you begin to understand in those ways what it might have meant to the folks who first read it, heard it, can you start to discern any meaning for the world today. Now, if you think understanding the world in ancient times is a tall order, the bigger one is understanding the world today.
The ancient world is in the past tense. It is, therefore, somewhat static. Studying the world of ancient times may be imperfect but it can be done.
But the world today is constantly changing. In short, asking about how something from Scripture might apply for us today is the hard part because the world changes around us daily and we often don’t even notice the change.
So we need to strive to understand the society of yesterday and today because we do not want to the prejudices of either yesterday or today to be involved in God’s message. If we can block out the prejudices of society in ancient times and modern times, then we might hear the message God has for us both in our own situation and for the entire human race.
All that brings us back to the words from the work known as Romans (Quote): “At the appointed time, when we were still powerless, Christ died for godless people.” For me, the meaning of this returns to the simplicity of covenant.
This should be clear: if Christ died even for (quote) for “godless people” Christ died for everyone. This is, therefor, a message of inclusiveness. You see, society in ancient times did have prejudices. Society today does have prejudices. My position is we may have prejudices but God does not.
God does not say ‘if a person is imperfect they are unacceptable.’ God does not say ‘people who are right handed will make the cut.’ So if we do like this hymn and we don’t like another hymn, that does not matter to God. God still accepts us. God listens to our hymns, all of them. And yes, hymns are a cup dipped into the flowing stream of artistic interpretation about God.
And yes, no matter who we are, no matter where we are on life’s journey, God accepts us as we are— each of us, all of us. In fact, God accepts us now and forever, for all eternity. This is a basic Biblical message.
I believe Scripture does not present God as a set of stumbling blocks, a set of tests to be conquered. Scripture addresses what it feels like to be loved by God. (Slight pause.)
I referenced this last week. It seems to me we humans spend a lot of time choosing up sides. Indeed, as a musician, as a lyricist, people sometimes ask me what music I like. I think that’s one of the strangest questions I have ever heard since it’s is a question about choosing sides.
The deciding factor for me, especially when it comes to hymns, is the simple one Brian Wren proposed. Music is that cup dipped into the great flowing stream of artistic Biblical interpretation. Music, hymns are meant to be a work of art for today which strive to help us understand Scripture for today.
So, for me, what Scripture says is simple and is for today: God loves everyone, no exceptions. I think the one thing we need to remember in this time of Lent is that with the advent of the Christ Scripture is about our salvation and about universal salvation. Why? The message with the advent of the Christ is simple: God loves everyone. Amen.
Elijah Kellogg Church, Harpswell, Maine
03/08/2026
ENDPIECE: It is the practice of the Pastor to speak after the Closing Hymn, but before the Choral Response and Benediction. This is a précis of what was said: “Historically hymns are a way people remember theology. There are many hymns which convey very good theology but there are unfortunately even more which convey astoundingly poor theology. So for me as a writer of hymns striving to reflect good theology— that’s a great burden. All of which is to say I do urge you to pay attention to a hymn as it is sung, even if you don’t know it or don’t like it. Ask yourself ‘what is the theology found therein?’ Do I hear theology which I think will withstand the test of time?”
BENEDICTION
Let us rest assured that God is among us and travels with us daily. Let us know that God’s Spirit empowers us to do things in the name of God we did not think possible. Therefore, let us share our love for God with others, confident that God will provide if we are faithful. And may we love God so much, that we love nothing else too much. May we be so in awe of God that we are in awe of no one else and nothing else. Amen.
[1] The article can be found here:
http://www.christianitytoday.com/ct/2011/march/hymnsthatkeepgoing.html